Skip to main content

College Insurance Company

Colchester, Vermont·EIN 02-0630294·NTEE Y200 · Mutual & Membership Benefit·501(c)(3)·Filing year 2024

College Insurance Company's highest-paid officer, the President/chair, was reported at $147,167 for 2024 (IRS Form 990), including base pay and other compensation. Reported CEO pay ranged from $93,624 to $147,167 between 2023 and 2024.

Total revenue
$36.3M
Total assets
$88.1M
Total expenses
$34.9M
Reported officers
28

How College Insurance Company’s pay compares

Compared with Mutual & Membership Benefit organizations of similar size nationwide.

There were too few similar organizations to compare with, so this group goes beyond Vermont.

In line with peers

Most of the roles College Insurance Company reports are paid within the middle half of what these Mutual & Membership Benefit organizations pay for the same roles.

Show how each role compares

From the officer pay College Insurance Company reported on its latest IRS Form 990.

COLLEGE PROVIDES VARIOUS INSURANCE COVERAGES TO EDUCATIONAL & INSTITUTIONAL INSURANCE ADMINISTRATORS, INC. (EIIA), AND ITS PARTICIPATING HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS, THAT ARE FAITH INSPIRED.

Executive compensation

Form 990 · Part VII & Schedule J · 5 reported individuals · Filing year 2024

Percentile bands compare each position's total pay with the same role at Mutual & Membership Benefit organizations of similar size nationwide. There were too few similar organizations to compare with, so this group goes beyond Vermont.

President/chair
25th percentile to median
$147k
Treasurer/secretary
25th percentile to median
$96k
Assistant Treasurer
Other
$79k
Assistant Secretary
Secretary (Operational)
$78k
Vp/assistant Secretary
Secretary (Operational)
$77k

Plus 23 unpaid individuals.

Browse compensation in Mutual & Membership Benefit →

Top pay as a share of expenses

In 2024, the highest total compensation at College Insurance Company equaled 0.4% of the organization's total expenses. The median for mutual & membership benefit organizations is 4%.

This organization (2024)
0.4%
Sector median
4%
Middle half of sector
0.9% to 12%

Based on 1,349 mutual & membership benefit organizations, each measured at its most recent filing year with reported expenses and compensation.

Up 45%
from 2023

From $102k in 2023 to $147k in 2024.

$102k
2023
$147k
2024
Pay for the position

Chief Executive Officer pay rose 57% from 2023 to 2024, while revenue rose 63%.

$94k in 2023 to $147k in 2024.
  • Chief Financial Officer pay fell 6% from 2023 to 2024.
  • Secretary (Operational) pay fell 8% from 2023 to 2024.

Pay for the position itself, not any one person. The officeholder may have changed between 2023 and 2024.

Highest reported compensation in each year. Volunteer board members and partial-year payouts are filtered out.

Among peers

Revenue and top compensation, plotted against similar organizations. This organization is highlighted in cyan.

Common questions about College Insurance Company

What does the Chief Executive Officer of College Insurance Company earn?

In 2024, the Chief Executive Officer of College Insurance Company received $147,167 in total compensation. This pay is below the median (the midpoint) for Chief Executive Officer roles among Mutual & Membership Benefit organizations of similar size nationwide, but above the bottom quarter of comparable filings. Based on IRS Form 990 data.

How does Chief Executive Officer pay at College Insurance Company compare with similar nonprofits?

Compared with the same role at Mutual & Membership Benefit organizations of similar size nationwide, the 2024 pay of the Chief Executive Officer at College Insurance Company falls between the 25th percentile and the median. In 2024, the highest total compensation at College Insurance Company equaled 0.4% of the organization's total expenses. The median for mutual & membership benefit organizations is 4%.

What are College Insurance Company's revenue and expenses?

In 2024, College Insurance Company reported $36.3M in total revenue and $34.9M in total expenses on its IRS Form 990.