Skip to main content

Mutual & Membership Benefit nonprofit Executive Director salaries

Based on 443 organizations from 2021 – 2024. Each org counted once at its most recent filing. Sourced directly from IRS Form 990, Schedule J.

Updated through 2024 · NTEE Y

Median total compensation
$39,500
The median mutual & membership benefit executive director earns $39,500 in total reported compensation.
Median across all 443 mutual & membership benefit nonprofits filing a Form 990, from the smallest to the largest
25th pct
$6k
75th pct
$154k
90th pct
$363k
443 organizations · 2021 – 2024

Where the middle 50% lands.

Half earn between $6k and $154k. That band is the interquartile range. The 90th percentile sits at $363k, roughly 9.2 times the median. That upper tail is where the largest organizations cluster.

PercentileTotal compMeans
90th$363,168Top 10% of earners
75th$153,96625% earn more than this
50th · median$39,500The typical executive
25th$6,12525% earn less than this
10th$76010% of executives earn less than this

How the package is built.

The typical pay structure across 107 organizations with full Schedule J reporting (24% of the 443 orgs in this slice). Each share is the average across orgs of the fraction of total comp that goes to this component, so the bar fills 100%.

$279,529
typical total · 2024
Median total compensation in the subset. The dollar amounts below show what each share works out to on a package this size.
81%
Base salary
81.2% of total
$226,978
Bonus & incentive
6.5% of total
$18,169
Retirement & deferred
5.2% of total
$14,536
Benefits
5.1% of total
$14,256
Other reportable
1.3% of total
$3,634
Shares are averaged across organizations, so they sum to ~100%. Dollar amounts are illustrative (share% of typical total) and don't reflect any specific org.

The number in context.

Every row links to its own dedicated benchmark page.

Executive DirectorThis page
$39,500
CFO
$15,135

All figures are median total reported compensation · IRS Form 990, Schedule J

Pay varies by state.

New York pays $31,488 more than the median Executive Director compensation in mutual & membership benefit nationally.

Top 10 states · Mutual & Membership Benefit Executive Director median
01
New York
47 orgs
$70,988
→

The ten highest-paid mutual & membership benefit Executive Directors by filing.

#OrganizationLocationTotal compensationFiling year
01Geisinger Insurance Corporation Risk Retention GroupDanville, PA$5,867,4232024
02Sutter Insurance Services CorporationHonolulu, HI$3,044,0142023
03Young Men's Christian Association Retirement FundNew York, NY$2,445,4622024
04American Institute for Chartered Property Casualty UnderwritersMalvern, PA$2,437,3692023
05New York Hotel Trades Council & Hotel Association of New York Health Center inNew York, NY$2,385,6342023
06International City Management Association Retirement CorporationWashington, DC$2,140,0692023
07North Carolina Electric Membership CorporationRaleigh, NC$1,728,2962024
08America's Health Insurance Plans IncWashington, DC$1,561,3232024
09Good Samaritan Self Insurance Against MalpracticeWest Islip, NY$1,532,7932024
10The Actors' Fund of AmericaNew York, NY$1,004,0622024

Total includes base, bonus, other reportable, and deferred/retirement compensation per Schedule J.

What does a $X org pay?

Adjust the slider to your organization's revenue. The median Executive Director compensation for mutual & membership benefit nonprofits in that revenue band updates live.

Your organization's revenue
$1M–$3M
annual revenue
Under $100K$1M–$3MOver $100M
Median Executive Director comp · $1M–$3M
$103,083
68 organizations in this band
Percentile range for your band
25th percentile$29,172
50th percentile$103,083
75th percentile$199,448

Mutual & Membership Benefit Executive Director pay, answered

How much does a Mutual & Membership Benefit nonprofit Executive Director make?
The median total compensation for an Executive Director at a mutual & membership benefit nonprofit is $39,500, based on 443 organizations in IRS Form 990 filings. The middle 50% fall between $6,125 and $153,966.
What is the salary range for an Executive Director in Mutual & Membership Benefit nonprofits?
Pay ranges from $6,125 at the 25th percentile to $153,966 at the 75th and $363,168 at the 90th. The spread reflects differences in organization size, budget, and region within the sector.
Is this Mutual & Membership Benefit compensation data reliable?
Yes. It comes from IRS Form 990 filings, legal documents filed under penalty of perjury, not self-reported surveys. Figures cover 443 mutual & membership benefit nonprofits reporting an Executive Director.
Why does Mutual & Membership Benefit nonprofit Executive Director pay differ from other sectors?
Compensation reflects the typical organization size, revenue, and operating complexity of each sector. Larger, better-funded mutual & membership benefit organizations pull the upper percentiles higher, while smaller ones anchor the lower end.