Skip to main content
Updated through 2024NTEE Y · Mutual & Membership Benefit

Mutual & Membership Benefit nonprofitexecutive pay

Median top-executive pay across 1,359 mutual & membership benefit nonprofits, 2021 – 2024. Each organization is counted once at its most recent filing, using the highest-paid leader reported on IRS Form 990, Schedule J.

Organizations that provide benefits to their members, including fraternal societies, insurance, and pension and retirement funds.

Median executive pay
$26,876
The typical mutual & membership benefit nonprofit's highest-paid executive earns $26,876 in total reported compensation.
25th pct
$5k
75th pct
$87k
90th pct
$209k
1,359 organizations · 2021 – 2024
Percentile distribution

Where the middle 50% lands.

Half earn between $5k and $87k. That band is the interquartile range. The 90th percentile sits at $209k, roughly 7.8 times the median. That upper tail is where the largest organizations cluster.

PercentileTotal compMeans
90th$208,571Top 10% of earners
75th$86,84625% earn more than this
50th · median$26,876The typical executive
25th$5,00025% earn less than this
10th$1,40010% of executives earn less than this
By organization size

Bigger budgets, bigger paychecks.

Median executive pay rises with organization revenue. Each band shows the 25th, 50th, and 75th percentile of top-executive pay for mutual & membership benefit nonprofits in that revenue range.

Revenue band25thMedian75thOrgs
Under $1M$3k$10,400$34k807
$1M – $10M$24k$64,202$155k307
$10M – $100M$45k$101,380$245k199
$100M – $500M$57k$228,458$581k34
$500M – $1B$205k$725,665$778k7
Over $1B$1M$1,728,296$1.8M5
Revenue bands with fewer than 5 organizations are not shown.
Geography

Pay varies by state.

Illinois pays $29,941 more than the national median across mutual & membership benefit nonprofits.

By role

Benchmark a specific Mutual & Membership Benefit role

Drill into median pay for individual leadership roles within mutual & membership benefit nonprofits.

Board & trustee pay

Mutual & Membership Benefit board & trustee pay norms

20% of mutual & membership benefit nonprofits pay at least one board member or trustee, with a typical per-person payment of $10,200 across a median board of 3 paid members.

Organizations paying board members
20%
Median board pay
$10,200
Median paid board size
3
By filing type
Form 990: 26%
Form 990-EZ: 8%
Form 990-PF: 11%
Directory

Fraternal organizations, pension and retirement funds, cemeteries, and mutual benefit societies. Covers employee benefit plans, veterans organizations, and membership associations. There are 5,463 mutual & membership benefit organizations in our database with compensation data from IRS Form 990 filings. Use the table below to browse them, or sort by revenue, location, or number of reported executives.

Organizations in Mutual & Membership Benefit

5,463 organizations · Page 46 of 110

Name
City
State
Revenue
Executives
FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES 4048 INCKissimmeeFL$269k0
RHODE ISLAND MASONIC YOUTH FOUNDATION INCCranstonRI$269k3
AMON CARTER LAKE WATER SUPPLYBowieTX$269k0
ILWU LOCAL 142 VEBA TRUSTHonoluluHI$268k0
LOWER ANIMAS COMMUNITY DITCHAztecNM$268k0
KINSMAN MUTUAL TELEPHONE COMPANYKinsmanIL$268k1
AMERICAN LEGION SANER POST 228Powhatan PointOH$268k0
BENEVOLENT & PROTECTIVE ORDER OF ELKS #2166Deerfield BeachFL$268k2
WARWICK CEMETERY ASSOCIATIONWarwickNY$267k1
Sellersburg Moose Family Center 1757SellersburgIN$266k0
PHILADELPHIA AREA COOPERATIVE ALLIANCEPhiladelphiaPA$266k2
BOILERMAKERS LOCAL 363 SUPPLEMENTAL TRAINING & EDUCATIONAL FUNDBellevilleIL$266k0
Beth Alom Cemetery Association IncNew BritainCT$265k0
Colonial Memorial Park Association aka Colonial Memorial Park IncTrentonNJ$265k2
EMPLOYEE CONTRIBUTION VEBA TRUST ITHACA COLLEGEClintonIA$265k1
Plumbers and Steamfitters Local 521 Supplemental Health FundOnaWV$265k2
BETA RHO HOUSING CORPORATION ALPHA SIGMA ALPHAIndianapolisIN$264k0
DALLASTOWN AMERICAN LEGION POST 605 HOME ASSOCIATIONDallastownPA$264k0
STEPANSKI FAMILY CHARITABLE TRUSTPalm BeachFL$264k0
FERNWOOD CEMETERY ASSOCIATIONJamesburgNJ$263k3
Fraternal Order of Police - State Lodge 69CatonsvilleMD$263k1
WAIALUA WATER ASSOCIATIONHonoluluHI$263k0
Benevolent & Protective Order of Elks Lodge 1106BangorPA$263k2
Veovera Software OrganizationSan AnselmoCA$262k2
CITY OF SOUTH LAKE TAHOE VEBA HEALTH SAVINGS TRUSTSouth Lake TahoeCA$262k1
BETHLEHEM VOLUNTEER FIREMENS HOME ABethlehemPA$262k0
ROCKFORD POLICE RELIEF ASSOCIATIONRockfordIL$262k4
LOCAL 305 NPMHU WELFARE BENEFIT TRUSTRichmondVA$262k2
Knights of Columbus Ponce DeLeon Council 8074Punta GordaFL$261k0
FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES 4185 AERIEDecaturAL$261k0
HILLCREST CEMETERY OF LOUISVILLE INCMt WashingtonKY$261k0
NEW YORK ASIAN AMERICANS UNITED INCBrooklynNY$261k0
EDGEWOOD CEMETERYKnoxvilleTN$261k0
NJ STATE PAROLE OFFICERS PBA LOCAL #326BrickNJ$260k11
KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS COUNCIL 5677Cedar RapidsIA$260k0
AMERICAN UNITED LIFE INS CO WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN FOR POST-65 EMERITUS AGENTSIndianapolisIN$260k0
CENTER VALLEY MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COKittanningPA$259k4
MRT WELFARE BENEFIT TRUSTHoustonTX$259k1
SOUTH CAROLINA CAPTIVE INSURANCE ASSOCIATION INCColumbiaSC$259k0
SHENANGO VALLEY SONS OF ITALY LODGE 875SharonPA$258k0
North CA Mason Contractors Association BeneSys Desiree EatonPleasantonCA$258k0
Medical Staff of San Antonio Regional HospitalUplandCA$257k0
PASCACK VALLEY LOCAL #206 INCWestwoodNJ$257k3
FOXFIELD PRESERVE INCWilmotOH$257k2
PECAN GROVE CEMETERY INCDFarmervilleLA$256k0
PORT JEFFERSON LODGE 1379 LOYAL ORDER OF MOOSEMount SinaiNY$256k0
INSULATORS LOCAL 41 RETIREE INSURANCE FUNDFort WayneIN$256k0
Fraternal Order of the EaglesVashonWA$256k0
RURAL CEMETERY ASSOC OF HORNELLSVILLE N YHornellNY$255k2
LOCUST GROVE CEMETARY ASSOCIATION OF QUAKERTOWN NEW JERSEYFrenchtownNJ$255k0